In early December 1795, a jury in Craven County gathered over the body of James Apollis “Pollie” Averitt. He had drowned on a Monday evening while steering a boat home from New Bern, with the wind blowing fresh. The only others on board were his son, James Avery, and his son-in-law, Lewis Smith.
Jeremiah James, Junior, swore on 6 December 1795 that Pollie was trying to turn the boat when his oar missed the water. He fell “head over heels” into the water and swam toward shore. James and Lewis rowed hard to reach him, but just as they were about to take hold of him, he sank. Jeremiah wasn’t on the boat himself; he told the story “as this deponent was informed.”
The jury, with Joseph Clark as foreman, examined the body. They found that Pollie had “a violent stroke under the left Eye,” and that the eyelid of his right eye was half cut off, and they said that stroke was the cause of his death. The papers don’t say how he came by the injury.
Lewis Smith was a very new son-in-law. His marriage bond to Polly Avery is dated 31 October 1795, only weeks before the drowning.
Pollie’s name turns up in many forms: James Apolis Averett, James Apollas Everitt, Pollas Averitt, Polly Avery and Pollie Avery. “Pollie” seems to have been short for his middle name.
The deposition of Jeremiah James, Junior

Transcription (original spelling kept; my notes are in [brackets]):
December 6th 1795
Jeremiah James, Junior, being duly sworn deposeth and Saith, that he was well aquainted with the deceased whose name was Pollie Avery, that last Monday week [a week ago last Monday] in the evening the wind blowing fresh as this deponent was informed, the deceased stearing a boat, which had been down to new born [New Bern] and then returning, endeavouring to turn the boat and his oar missing the water, as he made the Stroke he tumbled head over heels into the Water and swum towards the Shore his son, and Son in law, being all that were on board strove hard to row the Boat towards him, and take him in, and as they were about to take hold of him, he unfortanately sunk
Sworn before Me Dec 6th 1795
Will. Tisdale J.P.
Jeremiah [his + mark] James
N.B. The Names of the two persons in the Boat were James Avery, & Lewis Smith,

The jury’s verdict

Transcription:
Dec 6th 95 Inquisition taken before Me William Tisdale the dead body lying [before them] in View The Jury being impanneled and duly Sworn [Sworn] having examined the body and heard the evidence, are of Opinion following, that the Dec’d [deceased] had a violent stroke under the left Eye and the eyelid of the right Eye was half cut off. which stroke was the cause of this [his?] death
Joseph Clark foreman
Southey Bond
Wm Mitchell
Jon Fellowes
Josiah Fisher
F Webber
Alexr Mitchell
Jereh Readin [Jeremiah]
Asa Bryan
John Hobday
William Tignor
Saml Young

[Ed. note: The one doubtful reading in the verdict is “this [his?] death.” The word looks like “this,” but “his” may be what was meant. If you read it differently, please let me know.]
Other records of Pollie
- 1764: Two 100-acre Pitt County grants dated 15 February 1764 are indexed under “James Everit Appollas” (on the Clay Root neck) and “James Apollas Everitt” (on Clay Root Creek, south side of the swamp).
- 1768: David Garrall sold Isaac Buck 50 acres on the east side of Clayroot Swamp in Pitt County on 21 May 1768 (proved at July Court 1769). The witnesses were James Averett and “James Apolis Averett,” both by mark. So there were two men named James Averitt in that neighborhood, and Pollie was a grown man by 1768.
- 1781–1791: On 16 February 1781, Pitt entry officer William Robson issued warrant No. 835 to survey 100 acres for “James Apollas Everitt” on the south side of Tar River, on both sides of Cow Swamp, joining Samuel White’s entry, John Simpson’s line, John Albritain’s line, Ephraim Brooks’s entry, James Nelson’s entry and William Edwards’s entry. On 7 February 1789, “James Apollas Averitt” signed over the warrant to Shadrach Tuten by his mark. The survey, made 16 November 1790 with John Moye and Isaac Brooks as chain carriers, was “for Shadrack Tuton assignee of Polly Avery.” The grant was issued to Tuten on 20 December 1791.
- 1795: In the December 1795 Craven County court minutes, “Pollas Averitt” is on the list of insolvents [people whose taxes could not be collected] for 1794, in Capt. Jones’s and Bryan’s districts. John Averitt is on the same list for 1793, in Capt. Jones’s district.
- 1795: Lewis Smith and John Smith signed a Craven County marriage bond on 31 October 1795 for Lewis to marry Polly Avery. Both men signed by mark.





Working theory: how these Averitts may fit together
Please read this part as a working theory, not as proven fact. No record I have found spells out these relationships. This is my best current guess at who’s who, based on the records above and others in my files. I am sharing it in case it helps someone else, or in case someone has a record that proves or disproves it.
For each person, I list the records first. The records are facts. How the people connect is the working theory, and I label it that way each time. Spellings in quotation marks are as written in the record.
James Averitt (thought to be born about 1708)
- 1756, Beaufort County court minutes: “A Deed Poll from James Averit to John Averit for two [blank] Acres of Land” was proved in court by John Hardee, one of the witnesses.
- 1 Sep 1758, Beaufort County deed (land later in Pitt): James Averitt sold land to “John Averitt Junr,” a planter of Johnston County, for £5. Witnesses: John Hardee and Henry Cannon.
- 9 Sep 1758, Beaufort County survey: 100 acres on the southeast side of the northeast prong of Clay Root Swamp, including “the Plantation whereon he now lives.”
- 1762 and 1763, Pitt County tax lists: James Averitt is listed.
- 18 Aug 1764, Pitt County deed: James sold 220 acres on Cabin Branch, south side of Tar River, to William Edwards, signing by mark. David Averrett was a witness.
- 27 Nov 1764, Pitt County deed: James gave land on the east side of the northeast prong of Clayroot Swamp, part of his 1761 patent, to John Averitt, “my beloved Son,” keeping a life estate for himself.
- 1768, Pitt County deeds: James witnessed, by mark, two deeds from David Garrall to Isaac Buck on the east side of Clayroot Swamp (9 Feb and 21 May 1768). On the second, “James Apolis Averett” witnessed with him.
- 13 Oct 1771, Pitt County deed (proved July Court 1774): James and John Averitt sold the plantation on the southeast side of the northeast prong of Clayroot Swamp, with their “Houses,” to John Simpson. Both signed by mark.
Working theory: James was the father of John Averitt. The 1764 deed proves he had a son named John; that this is the same John who later lived on Clay Root Swamp and in Craven is part of the theory. That James was also the father of James Apollis “Pollie” Averitt is a guess. His birth year of about 1708 is an estimate, not a recorded date.
John Averitt (thought to be born about 1737)
- 1756 and 1758, Beaufort County: the deed poll and the deed from James Averitt to “John Averit” and “John Averitt Junr” (see above) may be to him.
- 1764 and 1771, Pitt County deeds: the gift from his father and the joint sale to John Simpson (see above). In 1771 he signed with an “A” mark.
- 17 Feb 1780, Pitt County entry No. 425: John Averett entered 100 acres at the mouth of Run Branch, on the west side of Clay Root Swamp, joining Joseph Litchworth, “whereon John Averett’s House Stands.” The warrant was issued 27 Dec 1781. On 15 Apr 1787 he sold the warrant to Stephen Harris for £1, by his mark, with Stephen Gatlin as witness. James Gatlin surveyed it on 5 May 1787, and Harris received the grant.
- 5 Dec 1783, deed of gift: “John Averet” witnessed, by mark, with Isaac Gardner, Mary Smith’s deed of gift to Joseph Litchworth.
- September 1786, Craven County petition: a “John Avery” signed the petition from upper Craven against annexing part of Craven to Pitt. “David Avritt” signed it too.
- 1790 census, Craven County: “John Averite,” with 1 male 16 or over, 3 males under 16 and 5 females.
- December 1795, Craven County court minutes: John Averitt is on the list of insolvents for 1793, in Capt. Jones’s district.
- I have not found him in the 1800 census.
Working theory: the Clay Root John of 1780 and the Craven John of 1790 are the son of James Averitt. The three boys under 16 in his 1790 household probably included John Jr. and Samuel (a guess).
Jemima
- 4 Aug 1800, Craven County deed: the name first turned up in my research here. John Willis sold Joel Wall 40 acres on the north side of the Neuse, on the run of Swift Creek, beginning at “Wall corner of Kemp Patent.” The witnesses were “Jamima [her X mark] Averett” and “Talbitt Williams.” Talbot Williams proved the deed in court.
- 6 Jan 1797, Craven County marriage bond: John Smith to “Jemima Avery.” The bondsmen were John Smith and John Avery, both by mark.
Working theory: a Jemima may have been John Averitt’s wife. That is a guess. No record names John’s wife, and I don’t yet know whether the Jemima of 1797 and the Jamima of 1800 are the same woman, or how either of them fits.
John Averitt Jr.
- 11 Feb 1799, Craven County marriage bond: John Avery to Suckey Charlton. Bondsman: John Smith, by mark.
- 1800 census, Craven County: “John Averil,” with 1 male under 10, 1 male 16–25 and 1 female 16–25. He is listed next door to David Avritt, and George Charlton is listed right after him (see below).
- 21 Feb 1807, estate sale of Enoch Harris: a John Averit is among those owing debts to the estate. This is probably John Jr.
Working theory: John Jr. is the son of John Averitt (born about 1737) and one of the boys under 16 in the 1790 household. The census bracket of 16–25 in 1800 means he was born about 1775–1784.
Samuel Averitt
- 2 Aug 1801, Craven County marriage bond: Samuel Avery to “Polly Smith,” widow. Bondsman: John Avery. Both signed by mark.
- 1800 census, Craven County: further down the same page as David and John is a “Samuel Averit,” 45 or over, with two males 16–25 and a female 45 or over. I don’t yet know how he fits, or whether he is the Samuel of the 1801 bond.
Working theory: Samuel, the groom of 1801, is a son of John Averitt and one of the boys under 16 in the 1790 household. That rests on a guess, and the older Samuel on the 1800 page still has to be placed.
James Apollis “Pollie” Averitt
His records are listed above: the 1764 Clay Root grants, the 1768 deed he witnessed, the 1781 Cow Swamp entry he sold to Shadrach Tuten in 1789, the 1794 insolvent list and the 1795 inquest.
Working theory: Pollie is a son of James Averitt (born about 1708) and a brother of John Averitt. Both are guesses. The two Jameses witnessed the 1768 deed together and both lived around Clayroot Swamp, but no record names their relationship.
James Averitt (James Avery), son of Pollie
- 13 Jan 1794, Craven County marriage bond: John Gatlin and Weeks Chapman were bound to Gov. Richd. D. Spaight for a license for the marriage of “James Everett & Susannah Lawley,” of Craven County. Both bondsmen signed their names.
- December 1795, Craven County inquest: he and Lewis Smith were the two men in the boat when his father drowned. The deposition calls them Pollie’s son and son-in-law.

That James was Pollie’s son is stated in the inquest. That the James Everett of the 1794 bond is the same man is my reading.
Polly Avery and Lewis Smith
- 31 Oct 1795, Craven County marriage bond: Lewis Smith to Polly Avery. Bondsman: John Smith. Both signed by mark.
- December 1795, Craven County inquest: Lewis Smith was in the boat and is called Pollie’s son-in-law.
- I have not yet found either of them in a later record under these names.
Working theory: the “Polly Smith, widow” who married Samuel Avery on 2 Aug 1801 was Lewis Smith’s widow, Pollie’s daughter Polly. That is a guess. If it is right, and if Pollie and John were brothers, Samuel and his bride were first cousins.
This Polly Smith was not the widow of Cannon Smith of Pitt County. Cannon was still buying land in 1802 and 1803 and was still living in 1810.
David Averitt (died 1828) and the 1800 census
David Averitt of Swift Creek is not part of Pollie’s family as far as I know, but he lived right beside these Averitts. In the 1800 Craven County census he is listed as “David Avritt,” next door to “John Averil”:
- David Avritt: 2 males under 10, 1 male 26–44, 1 female under 10, 1 female 10–15 and 1 female 26–44.
- John Averil: 1 male under 10, 1 male 16–25 and 1 female 16–25.
- George Charlton is listed right after John, and Samuel Averit (45 or over) is further down the same page.
Other records put David in the same circle. He signed the September 1786 Craven petition as “David Avritt,” on the same petition as a “John Avery.” In 1804 he bought 100 acres on Swift Creek from George Charlton. The Charltons tie in on the other side too: John Jr. married Suckey Charlton in 1799, and George Charlton was the bondsman when an Eliza Avery married Isaac Sutton in Craven on 26 Apr 1798.
Working theory: James Averitt (born about 1708) may have been an older brother of David Averitt Sr., the Conetoe Creek patentee in Pitt County, who I believe was the father of David (died 1828). A David Averrett witnessed James’s 1764 deeds. If James and David Sr. were brothers, then John Averitt (born about 1737) and David (died 1828) were first cousins, and John Jr., living next door in 1800, was David’s first cousin once removed. This is a possibility only. No record I have found names the relationship.
Again, everything in this section is a working theory. I will update it as records turn up.




